Fyfe, J., and I. M. Held, 1990: The two-fifths and one-fifth rules
for Rossby wave breaking in the WKB limit. Journal of the Atmospheric
Sciences, 40(6), 697-706.
Abstract: A stationary Rossby wave, sinusoidal in longitude,
is slowly switched on, and the meridional propagation of the resulting
wave front through a shear flow is examined. Initially the flow is westerly
everywhere and therefore free of critical layers. The transition from reversible
to irreversible behavior as the wave amplitude is increased is described.
It is shown that under slowly varying conditions in an inviscid quasi-linear
model, a steady state is obtained if, and only if, the mean flow is decelerated
by less than two-fifths of its initial value as a result of the passage
of the wave front. If this passage causes a larger mean flow reduction,
a pile-up of wave activity in the shear layer culminates in the generation
of a critical layer, qualitatively as in Dunkerton's model of gravity wave-mean
flow interaction. This qualitative picture is shown to be preserved in
the quasi-linear model when the slowly varying assumption breaks down.
Fully nonlinear calculations show that these quasi-linear results are only
part of the story. Once the mean flow is decelerated by two-fifths of its
initial value in the fully nonlinear model, rapid wave breaking and irreversible
mixing occur in the shear layer. But more slowly developing wave breaking
also occurs for wave amplitudes that are too small to produce the two-fifths
deceleration. Overturning of contours can be shown to occur in the quasi-linear
slowly varying model once the mean flow has been decelerated by one-fifth
of its initial value, and this appears to be the critical value for wave
breaking to occur in the nonlinear integrations.