Sardeshmukh, P. D., and I. M. Held, 1984: The vorticity balance in the tropical upper troposphere of a general circulation
model. Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences, 41 (5), 768-778.
Abstract: The time mean vorticity balance in the summertime tropical upper troposphere
of an atmospheric general circulation model constructed at the Geophysical
Fluid Dynamics Laboratory is examined, with particular emphasis on the detailed
balance in the Tibetan anticyclone. The model produces a reasonable simulation
of the large-scale features of the northern summer 200 mb flow in the tropics,
without the inclusion of subgrid scale processes that strongly damp the
upper tropospheric vorticity. the vorticity balance is essentially nonlinear
and nearly inviscid. There is considerable cancellation between the stretching
and horizontal advection of vorticity by the time mean flow in the vicinity
of the Tibetan anticyclone, with much of the remainder balanced by vertical
advection and twisting. Mixing by the resolved transients is not negligible
in some regions, but considerably smaller than the horizontal advection
overall and less well correlated with the stretching. Subgrid scale mixing
(consisting only of a biharmonic horizontal diffusion) plays a negligible
role in this vorticity budget.
To relate this study to linear models of the stationary flow in the tropics,
the steady state barotropic vorticity equation on the sphere is linearized
about the GCM's July mean zonal flow at 200 mb and forced with the GCM's
July mean vortex stretching. It is found that the strength of the Tibetan
anticyclone can be reproduced only by including a very strong damping of
vorticity in this linear model. The strong damping needed by other authors
(e.g., Holton and Colton) in their linear diagnoses of the tropical upper
tropospheric vorticity balance is therefore interpreted as possibly accounting
for neglected nonlinearities, and not necessarily cumulus friction. Our
conclusions are, however, potentially suspect, since the terms in our vorticity
budget have considerable structure on the smallest scales that can be resolved
by the GCM.