Mellor, G. L., and T. Yamada, 1974: A hierarchy of turbulence closure models for planetary boundary layers. Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences, 31 (7), 1791-1806.
Abstract: Turbulence models centered on hypotheses by Rotta and Kolmogoroff are complex.
In the present paper we consider systematic simplifications based on the
observation that parameters governing the degree of anisotropy are small.
Hopefully, we shall discern a level of complexity which is intuitively attractive
and which optimizes computational speed and convenience without unduly sacrificing
accuracy.
Discussion is focused on density stratified flow due to temperature. However,
other dependent variables-such as water vapor and droplet density-can be
treated in analogous fashion. It is, in fact, the anticipation of additional
physical complexity in modeling turbulent flow fields that partially motivates
the interest in an organized process of analytical simplification.
For the problem of a planetary boundary layer subject to a diurnally varying
surface heat flux or surface temperature, three models of varying complexity
have been integrated for 10 days. All of the models incorporate identical
empirical constants obtained from neutral flow data alone. The most complex
of the three models requires simultaneous solution of 10 partial differential
equations for turbulence moments in addition to the equations for the mean
velocity components and temperature; the least complex eliminates all of
the 10 differential equations whereas a "compromise" model retains two differential
equations for total turbulent energy and temperature variance.
We conclude that all of the models give nearly the same results. We find
the two-differential-equation model particularly attractive.